Western Digital Drive With Leopard - File System Formatter Failed.

I just bought a 1TB Western Digital drive. I am stoked.

However, I tried to format the drive on my Mac (Leopard) and got the error “File system formatter failed” when I tried to format the disk as MacOS Extended (Journaled). Not cool.

I found this forum thread which suggested using multiple partitions to solve the problem. When I was trying this, I went into options and changed the partition scheme from Master Boot Record to GUID partition table. It formatted fine.

To test things further, I changed the scheme back to 1 partition, and left the format as GUID partition table. This time it worked flawlessly.

The GUID type says it will not work as a start up disk MacOS older than 10.4. So if you’re still on Panther you can’t boot up off my backup drive. Try not to cry too much.

Update: here’s a few reasons why GUID owns MBR

If you found this post helpful, please consider sharing to your network. I'm also available to help you be successful with your distributed systems! Please reach out if you're interested in working with me, and I'll be happy to schedule a free one-hour consultation.